jump to navigation

Predictions for OpenSim in 2010 January 15, 2010

Posted by justincc in opensim, opinion, secondlife, virtual-environments, virtual-worlds.

Hello folks. Having assessed my 2009 predictions at the end of last year, I meant to get this post out very shortly afterwards but, as so often, life intervened :). Still better a couple of weeks late than never, so here are my predictions for OpenSim in 2010. Just to conform with everyone else, I thought that I’d use the grand word ‘predictions’ this year instead of ‘guesses’.  This doesn’t ensure greater accuracy, though :).

  1. OpenSim will remain in alpha for 2010. OpenSim has progressed pretty well over the past year.  There have been many new features and a large number of bugs have been cleared up, including some really difficult race-condition related failures. However, OpenSim is a beast of a project and many, many issues remain.  Moreover, early on in the year we’ll see some significant refactoring in OpenSim – the simulator service architecture will see its final transition to the ROBUST framework and the central scene object classes will be redesigned.  These changes are essential but in the short term they will introduce bugs of their own and force anybody already interfacing with those parts of OpenSim to adapt.
    For these reasons, I don’t think that OpenSim will emerge from alpha in 2010.  However, I do think that stability will continue to improve in the second half of 2010, leading to significant pressure to label ourselves as beta early on in 2011.
  2. There will be a lot more experimentation with OpenSim in education and business contexts. Earlier in the year, I was very interested to read just how well known OpenSim was within the UK’s higher education system.  And I know that other countries are not too far behind and some (such as Australia) are probably a little bit ahead.  So I believe that education-related use of OpenSim will grow strongly in 2010, particularly in the second half as OpenSim’s stability and usability improve.  Business and innovators will also continue to experiment with OpenSim, but from what I’ve seen they require a level of platform stability that I don’t think that OpenSim will have in 2010.
  3. Both general-purpose and specific use grids will grow. Specific use grids such as ReactionGrid, a grid oriented towards educators and collaborators, grew significantly in 2009.  I don’t see why this shouldn’t continue in 2010.  Sciencesim, another research and education oriented OpenSim installation, is also making some very interesting moves, particularly with their recent Settlement Land collaboration with the Fashion Research Institute.  This program will award educators, scientists, and researchers with a free 1/4 region of land in ScienceSim for 6 months.  Naturally, this will encourage expansion of the ScienceSim grid.
    When I assessed my 2009 guesses I wasn’t too sure whether we had seen any growth in general-purpose grids.  There hadn’t been any obvious upswing in related blogging and no data was available.  However, Maria Korolov has recently come out with some December 2009 region numbers.  Comparing these to the numbers she had back in September 2009, the largest social grids appear to show significant growth (OSGrid up by 812 regions / 30%, The New World Grid up by 106 regions / 40%), though others have shrunk or folded.  So I’m going to make the prediction that these will continue to grow in 2009, though I don’t see network effects kicking in to make that growth exponential – the platform and environment isn’t suitable for that this year.
  4. Some form of OpenSim foundation will appear, maybe more than one. Various factors (slowly increasing popularity, historically high level of churn in the OpenSim code, development unpredictability) are beginning to produce calls for the establishment of formal organizations connected with OpenSim.  These don’t necessarily need to be directly connected with core code development – ScienceSim, for instance, is working on a proposal for a foundation to support a downstream distribution using OpenSim, among other services.  It’s quite possible for organizations like this to co-exist with an Apache-like organization that surrounds OpenSim itself.
    I think that at least one such foundation will come about this year.
  5. There will be a few more OpenSim distributions. An OpenSim distribution is a project that uses OpenSim as it’s base virtual environment/virtual world platform.  At one extreme a distribution could stick closely to what is in the OpenSim core project.  At the other end of the range it could significantly alter OpenSim features and swap in its own communication protocols.
    The OSGrid distribution, for instance, is close to the core OpenSim extreme while modrex (which enables the Realxtend environment) is closer towards the other end.
    I think that we will see a few more distributions in 2010, though I predict that they will tend towards bundling code, tools or modules surrounding OpenSim rather than significantly changing OpenSim’s base functionality. I think that the economic and virtual environment sector isn’t at the right stage for the level of investment required to significantly adapt OpenSim, notwithstanding the existing Realxtend effort.
  6. The vast majority of OpenSim access will continue to be through the Linden Lab viewer and its direct descendents. I said this last year but I still think that it holds true.  In fact, as I noted in my 2009 assessment, a lot of the non-Linden derived viewer projects have fallen inactive.  There are some promising new ones but a year is not long enough, in my opinion, to get them seriously underway.
  7. Cross grid experimentation will continue but not go mainstream. Again, a prediction that carries over from last year.  Work is still being done on projects such as Hypergrid and Grider, but I don’t think that the environment is mature enough yet to bring these to more general notice.  Fundamental security issues remain with the current version of Hypergrid that, in my view, greatly hamper serious experimentation. However, I continue to think that in the long term, Hypergrid 2.0/Grider is a very promising architectural approach for a properly distributed network of virtual environments, one that overcomes the current security issues.
  8. OpenSim will start to support mesh objects. There’s significant interest in mesh objects and with the upcoming scene object refactor it will be significantly easier to support these as a native object within OpenSim.  Of course, one has to have a suitable viewer to make use of this – Realxtend’s Naali and 3di’s Rei have support for meshes and the new ‘2.0’ Second Life viewer was reported to include them too, though apparantly this is an unfounded rumour. Nonetheless, I expect that the OpenSim server will natively support the storage of meshes in some form before 2010 is out.


1. Zauber Paracelsus - January 15, 2010

Sirikata’s viewer will natively support meshes as well 🙂

2. Marcus Llewellyn - January 15, 2010

If #8 comes true I’ll kiss the all devs that make it happen! Well, maybe not all of them. Some of them will run away too fast for me to catch.

Sculpts require in inordinate amount of time to work with. You have to torture a comformant mesh something horrible most of the time, and the extra steps needed to texture them are just plain silly.

I’d also like to see support for normal maps on these meshes. I’d even say this was essential for encouraging creators to keep mesh polygons down, and might even make LOD more tolerable in some cases.

3. Tweets that mention Predictions for OpenSim in 2010 | justincc.org -- Topsy.com - January 15, 2010

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mal Burns, Terry Thorpe (Kohd), Dom Raban, taovacano, Peter Stindberg and others. Peter Stindberg said: Predictions for OpenSim in 2010 http://ff.im/-elwmW […]

4. Nink - January 18, 2010

I hope your wrong about number 1. Opensim is much more stable than dozens of other “Beta” and GA code virtual world platforms. Education and research will experiment with Alpha but companies will continue to shy away from the Opensim if it is Alpha and we will not see any large customers jump on board in a serious way until we get out from under the Alpha monica.

5. justincc - January 18, 2010

@Nink – I agree about the shying away, but in some respects that’s precisely why the alpha tag is in place. I think we would do long-term damage to our credibility if we dropped it before we felt that the project was ready.

6. Kimberly Winnington/Gianna Borgnine - January 20, 2010

Hi! Nice predictions. I just wanted to make a comment about number 8. Thank you for linking to our blog about Mesh Support in SL. I want to clarify that Mesh Support in SL is not a rumor, it just will not be part of SL 2.0. I have personally been using SL 2.0 alpha for over a month now. While it is great as far as the look and organization goes, there are no new features that I noticed. It really is only about the new UI design. Having stated that, I know others who are currently using the alpha version of Mesh Support and they say it is working great! Open Beta versions of both SL 2.0 and Mesh Support are supposed to be coming early in February. It will be interesting to see what OpenSim does with Mesh as well!

7. Reed Steamroller - January 20, 2010

Mesh support not being included in Second Life 2.0 does not mean that it isn’t coming. It is already in closed alpha stage. People are using it now.

To say otherwise is very misleading.

8. justincc - January 20, 2010

@Kimblerly, @Reed – Thanks for the information.

9. David Miller - January 22, 2010

Great list! Indeed you will see more corporate and educational use. I used to speak about using Second Life as an eLearning application (to create video, not to do teaching in) but now am only doing presentations about OpenSim (namely Reaction Grid).

Once we get our little grid squared away, we will come on like gang busters evangelising OpenSim! (lol, the other part of “we” is Ener Hax – that’s a one heck of a spin machine!).

Thank you Justin for the work that you so passionately do and for creating a truly wonderful alternative to Second Life.

10. justincc - January 26, 2010

@David – Thanks David – the more guys like you we have in our community the better 🙂

11. David Miller - January 28, 2010

thanks for the encouragement Justin, I am loving OpenSim very much. Have one speaking gig in Chicago about it and seeing about a second conference.

12. Shaspa - Smart Shared Spaces , Smart Home, Smart Building - May 29, 2010

Shaspa 3D Operations Centers…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: